Magistrate Desmond Nair announced the decision after impassioned final
arguments from the defense and the prosecution in Courtroom C of the
Pretoria Magistrate’s Court.
The magistrate said Mr. Pistorius did not represent a flight risk and
was not likely to interfere with state witnesses. “The accused has made a
case to be released on bail,” he concluded, while the prosecution had
not established a case for detaining him. Pistorius’s family members in
the packed courtroom shouted, “Yes!”
Magistrate Nair set bail at 1 million rand, about $112,000, and ordered a
series of conditions before the case was adjourned to June 4. Mr.
Pistorius was told to relinquish firearms and passports and to avoid his
upscale home in a gated community where he shot to death his
girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp, in what he has called an accident and
prosecutors have called premeditated murder. The home is now a crime
scene.
The unusually tight restrictions on Mr. Pistorius also included a
prohibition on making contact with witnesses. The athlete was also told
that he could not leave the Pretoria area without official permission
and could not use drugs or alcohol while the trial was pending. He was
instructed to report to a police station twice a week.
Arnold Pistorius, an uncle who has acted as family spokesman, told
reporters: “We are relieved by the fact that Oscar got bail today, but
at the same time, we are in mourning for Reeva Steenkamp and her
family.”
But Kim Myers, a friend of Ms. Steenkamp, said: “I think it is important to remember that someone lost their life.”
“We trust and hope that justice will prevail.”
Before announcing his ruling, the magistrate recounted the four days of
conflicting arguments by defense and prosecution lawyers. Mr.
Pistorius’s shoulders shook with emotion and tears fell from his eyes
as, at one point, Magistrate Nair said, “The deceased died in his arms.”
Magistrate Nair took issue particularly with the testimony and actions
of the prosecution’s lead investigator, Detective Warrant Officer Hilton
Botha, who has since been removed from the case, saying the officer
made “several errors and concessions” and “blundered” in gathering
evidence.
“It is his evidence that may have been tarnished by cross-examination,
not the state case,” Magistrate Nair said. At the same time, the state
case was not so “strong and watertight” that Mr. Pistorius “must come to
the conclusion that he has to flee,” he said.
In a two-hour summary of the case and of the laws governing bail, the
magistrate also read a series of character references from the athlete’s
friends, who described his relationship with Ms. Steenkamp, a
29-year-old model and law school graduate, as loving and happy.
The prosecution had opposed the sprinter’s application to be released on
bail until a full trial, arguing that he might flee. It said Mr.
Pistorius, 26, murdered Ms. Steenkamp when he fired four shots through a
locked bathroom door at his home on Feb. 14 while she was on the other
side.
The sprinter, who underwent double amputation as an infant after being
born without fibula bones and uses prostheses, has said he believed that
the person in the bathroom was an intruder and he never intended to
kill Ms. Steenkamp.
Magistrate Nair said that while the prosecution case rested on “nothing
more than circumstantial evidence,” there were “improbabilities that
need to be explored” in Mr. Pistorius’s account of events.
“The only person who knows what happened there is the accused,” he said.
But, he went on, “I cannot find that it has been established that the
accused is a flight risk.”
Ultimately, he said, Mr. Pistorius had helped his case for bail by
providing a sworn affidavit to the court setting out his version of
events.
Mr. Nair cited legal requirements that the defense must establish
“exceptional circumstances” to qualify for bail in cases of premeditated
murder, the most serious murder charge under South African criminal law
which carries a mandatory life sentence, with parole after 25 years at
the latest.
He also said bail hearings were not about guilt or innocence, but about
whether justice was served by holding defendants in custody. Mr.
Pistorius’s lawyer, Barry Roux, said Friday that if he were prosecuting
the case, the charge would be culpable homicide — a less serious charge
implying either negligence or a lack of intention to kill.
Prosecutors say judges decide the sentence for culpable homicide
depending on the circumstances. With his head bowed and his jaw clenched
as he entered the court on Friday in advance of the bail ruling, Mr.
Pistorius appeared to be struggling to hold back tears, as the
prosecutor, Gerrie Nel, described Ms. Steenkamp’s plight on Feb. 14.
“I am not saying the planning of the murder of Reeva Steenkamp happened
weeks ahead, days ahead,” Mr. Nel said. “I am saying the planning to
kill Reeva Steenkamp happened that night.”
Ms. Steenkamp took refuge in the bathroom to escape either a fight or a gun, he said.
But, during a morning session before the bail ruling, Magistrate Nair
seemed skeptical on Friday about the risk of flight by Mr. Pistorius.
“What kind of life would he lead, a person who has to use prostheses, if
he has to flee” and found himself “ducking and diving every day” on
artificial limbs, the magistrate asked.
“A life not in prison,” Mr. Nel replied, comparing Mr. Pistorius to the
WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, who has taken refuge in the Ecuadorean
Embassy in London, despite his “famous face.”
Piling on emotional pressure on Friday, Mr. Nel linked the death of Ms.
Steenkamp to other violence against women in South Africa, including the
case of Anene Booysen, a 17-year-old who was raped and murdered in the
Cape region earlier this month. “The degree of violence present in this
case is horrific,” Mr. Nel said.
The athlete’s longtime coach, Ampie Louw, told reporters on Friday that
he was considering putting the athlete back in training “to get his mind
clear.”
Mr. Pistorius has canceled planned track appearances and several
corporate sponsors, including Nike on Thursday, have distanced
themselves from him.
“The sooner he can start working, the better,” Mr. Louw said.
In an aside to the case, the South Africa edition of Heat, a celebrity
gossip magazine, on Friday published what it said was Ms. Steenkamp’s
last interview, a week before her death, in which she said the couple
had not been discussing their relationship publicly in the media
“because I don’t want to get it tainted.”
“I don’t want anything coming in the way of his career,” she said,
according to an advance excerpt from the interview. “He’s such an
amazing athlete.
“You know what they do, they make things up, ‘Reeva cheats on Oscar,’
and rubbish like that. I wouldn’t want lies about us jeopardizing it.”
CULLED FROM www.newyorktimes.com
No comments:
Post a Comment